CHRONOLOGY & CATASTROPHISM REVIEW VOLS. XII (1990) and XIII (1991). ARTICLE ABSTRACTS/EXTRACTS

Chronology & Catastrophism REVIEW Vol. XII, 1990                  Click here for cost

[This issue also contains a Letters section 'continuing the exchange of views begun in Review vol. XI.  T. William Field and David Salkeld debate the mechanics of inversion of the tippe-top (as it relates to an Earth inversion in the Warlow hypothesis); .......'] 

 
Homeric Troy and the Greek Dark Age, by Dwardu Cardona
 
Should Homer's Illiad be seen as an accurate historical account? Whilst agreeing with David Rohl on the need to abolish the non-existent Dark Age of Greece, Dwardu Cardona argues that the Illiad is nothing but a poetic saga and that Homer's Troy has yet to be discovered. 
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
 
Essays on Early Greek History in the light of the New Chronology - Essay Two:The Greek Colonisation Movement - When and Why?, by David Rohl
 
The reasons why the ancient Greeks went overseas and founded colonies in the Aegean and Italy are explored, and the question is asked 'when' this occurred. David's chronological revision varies significantly from that of Velikovsky, although both find that many problems and anomalies are solved with a lowering of the orthodox chronology.
___________________________________________________________________________________________
 
The Erratic Descent of Man, by Dr. Trevor Palmer
 
In studying the evolution of one species there are lessons to be learnt about evolution in general. Here, Dr. Palmer concentrates on Man, discovering that although Man has been particularly extensively studied, surprisingly few firm conclusions can be drawn concerning his descent.  
___________________________________________________________________________________________
 
Interdsciplinary Indiscipline, by Dick Atkinson
 
In this article, Velikovsky's early critics and detractors are scrutinised by a non-Velikovskian. Famous names in the scientific world are here associated with the infamous words written or uttered by them, with particular reference to Isaac Asimov and those who have cited him as an 'authority'. 
  ___________________________________________________________________________________________
age]  

Early 21st Dynasty Genealogy and the Consequences of Redating the Installation of HPA Pinudjem I to ca. Year 1 of Psusennes I, by Jeremy Goldberg

In his detailed study of the complexities of the genealogy of the 21st Dynasty, Jeremy Goldberg argues for a radical revision of the currently accepted scheme of things. In so doing, he finds himself at odds with the 'New Chronology' even though the direction of his revision is also towards a lower chronology. Central to his argument is the relationship between the installation of HPA Pinudjem I and Year I of Psusennes I; consequent upon it would be an overlap between Dynasties 20 and 21 plus a revision of the currently accepted relationship between Dynasties 21 and 22. 
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
                                                                                                                                 
Chronology & Catastrophism REVIEW Vol. XIII, 1991                  Click here for cost          
   

Earth Tectonics Viewed from Rock Mechanics, by Prof. Melvin A. Cook

According to Carey's Rheid theory, which underpins modern Continental Drift theory, even granite will flow like a liquid given enough time. Prof. Cook offers his alternative based on the science of rock mechanics, a rapid split of the primordial super-continent. 
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
 
The Archaeology of Shiloh and Pottery Chronology, by Bob Porter
 
Bob Porter examines the excavation reports for Shiloh, noting some chronological anomalies. In resolving these he produces a radically new interpreetation of pottery chronology for the MB/LB/Iron ages.
[ _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
 
Should the European Oak Dendrochronologies be Re-examined?, by Jesse Lasken
 
In the first of three articles reviewing dendrochronology and calibrated radiocarbon dates, Jesse Lasken questions the soundness of the Irish and German oak chronologies and their independence, both from one another and from the Bristlecone Pine chronology in the USA. 
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
 
Calibrated Radiocarbon and 'the Methodological Fault-Line', by Bernard Newgrosh
 
Examines the difficulties caused, even for conventional historians, by the application of calibrated radiocarbon dates. 
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
 
A Bit Creaky? - Tree Rings, Radiocarbon and Ancient History, by Alasdair Beal
 
In another critical examination of the statistics and methodology of the dendrochronologists, Alasdair Beal argues for an interdisciplinary approach to the problem of absolute dating. 
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________