This is an enjoyable book with a clear hero – and an accompanying villain. Robin Heath, ‘Alexander Thom: Cracking the Stone Age Code‘ [Secrets of the Circle Builders] published by Bluestone Press, St Dogmaels:2007. He wrote the book with a lot of help from Archie Thom, the eldest son of Alexander, and Archie’s sister, Beryl Austin, and various other members of the Thom family. He also interviewed Aubrey Burl and Euan MacKie and various other well known, to him, characters such as Keith Critchlow and John Michell. It all begins with an interesting foreword by Beryl, followed by a lengthy Introduction to the family history as a whole. One thing jumped out at me. Thom was reared on a farm in Argyll, a highland location with no lights at night so he was intensely aware of the night sky above. Another point also caught my attention. Beryl on the Royal Society meeting with her father as outlined in the previous post.
Robin Heath doesn’t always pull his punches. He says the whole Thom package has been effectively airbrushed out of the academic study of prehistory – but the book’s title tells its own story. His aim, he says, is to present anew that body of research by Thom as the man himself had a massive output unrivalled by anyone that has come since. Thom had turned his attention to the stone circles of Scotland and nearby regions as the focus of his retirement project. A bit like CA Newham choosing Stonehenge as a retirement project. Thom’s surveys were over a very wide area of a little known and isolated part of Britain that had clearly had a healthy population in the past but that has now dramatically declined for various reasons. It is full of stone circles. He was puzzled by their presence and was also, as an engineer, keen on picking them apart with his theodolite in order to get into the minds of the circle builders. What was all the effort about? As an engineer, Thom, claims Heath, was presented with a situation akin to being given a complex piece of equipment with no operation manual. Hardly a problem to somebody used to solving problems such as an engineer. Archaeologist Atkinson described Thom’s book as a well aimed parcel bomb. However, Heath says the explosion was contained by the archaeological community, constrained by the profession so much so that Thom’s name may be widely known but his work is still not understood.
This book was published around 27 years after Professor Wood’s book that had ended on an optimistic note on the role that Thom might play in that future. Within books on prehistoric archaeology Thom does not usually get a mention. He became persona non grata according to Heath. There is a bit of treacle being labelled about here as Heath also claims that one reason he is not acceptable to archaeologists is because he was an engineer, somebody that gets their hands dirty, unlike your average academic. That is a strange view of your average man with a trowel as they do such things as sift through middens full of broken sea shells and vomit, very smelly rubbish pits and ancient latrines, even the odd cess pit. If that ain’t getting your hands dirty I don’t know what to say. He goes on then to say that the man who effectively fathered the subject of astro-archaeology, now generally referred to as archaeo-astronomy, is forgotten, even though there is now a chair of the subject at Leicester University. I think you might get a whiff of what follows.
to be continued