At https://phys.org/print405078446.html … the mechanism for photosynthesis existed in primeval microbes. Will this put an end to the idea of earth as a satellite of Saturn? Thunderbolts and the Saturn Theory are like a hand and a glove but what does this study mean for the idea of solar system re-arrangement. Photosynthesis creates oxygenised carbohydrates such as glucose from solar energy, water, and co2 (carbon). It is indispensable for many species on this planet. Whilst this makes the 'co2 is evil' meme of the CAGW crowd the height of absurdity it does also create a problem for the Saturnists (amongst several other problems).